1. Fr. Timothy Jock 1911–1916
  2. Rt. Rev. Exarch Cyril Aneid 1916–1921
  3. Rev. Peter Nahas 1921–1926
  4. Rt. Rev. Archimandrite Joseph Kandalaft 1926–1934
  5. Rev. Raphael Gedah, BSO 1934–1963
  6. Rev. John Nasser 1963–1967
  7. Rev. John Orlowski 1967–1968
  8. Rev. Elias Njaim 1968–1970
  9. Rev. Ronald Golini 1970–1977, 1978–1979
  10. Rev. Alexander Kelliher, S.A. 1977-1978
  11. Rev. Damon Geiger, O.Ss.T 1979–1982
  12. Rev. Frank Milienewicz 1982–1988
  13. Rev. Paul Frechette 1988–1990
  14. Rev. Cyril Crume 1990–1992
  15. Deacon Dimitry Kamolov, administrator 1992–1995
  16. V. Rev. Philaret Littlefield 1995–2017
  17. Mr. Benjamin Newman, administrator 2017–present